Archive for January 15th, 2009


Australia: Speed Camera Accuracy Under Fire

Author: goldiron
January 15, 2009

Australia: Speed Camera Accuracy Under Fire
Partial disclosure of information shows major electrical faults with speed cameras in Queensland, Australia.

Police Minister Judy SpenceSpeed cameras in Queensland, Australia have not been well maintained, according to documents obtained by the Courier-Mail newspaper. The investigation found numerous cases of electrical faults that call into question the underlying accuracy of the readings produced by the devices.

“Main Roads has advised that electrical work does not comply with Australian electrical standards and Queensland Police Service staff are not permitted to open the crown pole without an electrician present,” a police report stated.

Officials only allowed the release of 22 out of 77 relevant documents, concealing information regarding problems with data logging devices by claiming that they contained “trade secrets.” The Police Minister even went so far as to conceal the identity of the contractors paid $1.3 million to provide the electrical work, insisting that to do so might endanger the company.

North of Brisbane on the Bruce Highway, for example, a document showed that a camera short-circuited during a heavy rain storm in January 2007. Cameras with similar problems continued to issue citations at the rate of 4000 per month, on average. Police Minister Judy Spence insisted that no citation issued by a speed camera in Queensland has been found inaccurate because each speed camera can verify accuracy internally.

“There were some electrical faults initially but when those faults occurred the speed cameras turned off, so people weren’t caught in any fashion because of some fault in the camera,” Spence told the Courier-Mail.

Source: Broken cameras lead to questions over speeding tickets (Brisbane Courier-Mail (Australia), 1/1/2009)


Review of State Motorcycle Safety Program Technical Assessments

A key effort initiated by NHTSA, aimed at promoting motorcycle safety and understanding the factors that contribute to motorcycle crashes, is the State Motorcycle Safety Program Technical Assessments (”State Assessments”), which provide comprehensive reviews of State motorcycle safety programs and practices. During the assessments, reviewers examine the policies States have implemented to promote motorcycle safety and offer recommendations for additional steps States may take to encourage safe riding and reduce crashes, injuries, and fatalities.

NCSA Technical Report (DOT-HS-811-082) Jan 2009

PDF 54 pages:

http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/portal/nhtsa_static_file_downloader.jsp?file=/staticfiles/DOT/NHTSA/NCSA/Content/Reports/2009/811082.pdf


Red-light cameras may return

Author: goldiron
January 15, 2009

Red-light cameras may return

State transportation officials want to revive the use of cameras that snap pictures of cars that are midway through an intersection when the light is red.

And that’s just the first of five proposals from state transportation officials to clamp down on bad driving.

Also to go before lawmakers next week:

  • Requiring moped and motor scooter riders to wear a helmet.
  • Fining commercial drivers found to have even trace amounts of alcohol in their blood.
  • Expanding the definitions of reckless driving laws for first-timers and repeat offenders.
  • And banning cell phones, even hands-free devices, for teenage drivers.
  • “We need to change driver behavior to provide for safer roads,” said Brennon Morioka, state Department of Transportation director, during a news conference yesterday to announce the proposals. “These measures are meant to work in concert with each other. There is no one silver bullet to provide safety on our roads.”

    The numbers show that the state has a lot of work to do, Morioka said. Hawai’i leads the nation with the highest number of alcohol-related traffic fatalities, is third highest in the nation for motorcycle fatalities and fourth for pedestrian fatalities. Judging by the first five days of the year, 2009 hasn’t been any better. There are five fatalities so far: They include a cyclist, and three that occurred separately on New Year’s Day.

    On the Big Island, traffic deaths have caused concerns, said Dr. Sharon Vitousek, director of the North Hawai’i Outcomes Project, a grassroots organization targeting traffic safety.

    “The problem is there are too many people dying each year from traffic crashes,” Vitousek said. “Many are preventable. It’s a matter of changing behavior and making policy changes.”

    On average, there are 140 traffic fatalities a year in Hawai’i. The goal is to get the numbers down to 100 and that’s still too high, Morioka said.

    “We have the ability to change this,” said Gov. Linda Lingle. “The need for collaboration has never been greater in our state, not just politicians, but the community, to make life better and safer. As these proposals show you, you don’t need a lot of money to make changes. They’re just changes in policy.”

    Idea dismissed in 2005

    So-called “van cams,” roving vans equipped with cameras intended to catch drivers running red lights, were approved by the Legislature in 2001 but later repealed in the wake of public outcry. A similar concept that would have given counties the authority to use red-light cameras resurfaced in 2005 and won state House approval, but was killed in the Senate.

    Sen. J. Kalani English, D-16th (E. Maui, Moloka’i, Lana’i), said he doesn’t advocate red-light cameras, but will give the proposal a chance. The measure would give the counties the revenue from fines collected from drivers caught midway through an intersection when the light is red. Fines would run from $90 to $200.

    “The Senate has always said no to the bill,” English said. “I put the idea before our (Democratic) caucus and it went from absolute no to hmmm. So we’ve made a lot of progress.”

    Morioka said 21 other states have some form of law allowing snapshots of driving scofflaws.

    “It’s intended to save lives,” Morioka said. “These bills are meant to shape some of the decisions that our drivers are making on our roads.”

    As for the outright ban on cell phones and other devices that could distract new, young drivers, 2001-05 statistics show 7 percent of vehicle crashes involved drivers 15 to 17 years old.

    The ban would include cell phones, video games, portable DVD players and text messaging, as well as eating, drinking or grooming while driving. Offenders would have their license suspended for three to six months.

    English says the measure would be the first step toward an outright ban for all drivers, the theory being children will follow the law and force their parents to follow suit. At the same time, the Hono- lulu City Council is considering a ban on text messaging while driving for all motorists.

    “These are the people (teen- agers) who are supposed to be learning how to drive and don’t need any distraction,” Morioka said.

    Helmets part of plan

    For moped and motor scooter riders, a helmet would be required under the state’s traffic safety package. Motorcyclists are exempt from the measure.

    “It’s another bill that will be very controversial,” Morioka said. “We’re targeting mopeds and motorscooters because they’re smaller and less powerful in terms of maneuvering than motorcycles and usually less experienced drivers operate them.”

    Reckless drivers who speed excessively, weave in and out of traffic and drive while drowsy are being targeted with a measure that would fine violators up to $1,000 and could include up to 30 days in prison, depending on the number of offenses.

    “Aggressive and reckless driving has been the main components of many of our accidents,” Morioka said.

    Also under consideration is a measure that would significantly lower the legal limit of alcohol for drivers using a commercial driver’s license. Even trace amounts of more than 0.01 percent would be subject to a fine of up to $200 and those found with a blood alcohol level of 0.04 percent would be subject to a $500 fine. The legal limit for all drivers is 0.08 percent blood alcohol.

    “The measures are part of a larger plan,” Morioka said. “The bills are meant to protect. All of our partners have reviewed all of our bills. Motorists, bicyclists and pedestrians will benefit from each one of these.”


    Noise abatement law draws loud protest

    Author: goldiron
    January 15, 2009

    Noise abatement law draws loud protest

    Loud noise from motorcycles’ engines may have caused the City Council to consider cracking down further on illegal exhaust systems, but loud noise from the bikers’ themselves has resulted in further review of the penalties.

    A proposed City Council bill that would enforce stiff penalties on motorcycles with loud exhaust systems has been sent back for further review after protests from motorcycle enthusiasts and City Councilmember Leroy Comrie.

    “Having to purchase an additional sticker you have to pay for - it’s just an additional tax on motorcycle riders,” said Joseph Bechtold, representing the Local 3 motorcycle club in Astoria. He rides a stock Harley Davidson.

    City Councilmember Peter Vallone proposed last month to enforce stiff penalties - which could have resulted in seizure of the bike on only the second offense - on motorcycles missing a sticker from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). These stickers would verify the bike was free of a “straight pipe,” an illegal exhaust pipe system without baffles, thus causing loud noise.

    Since the bill was originally intended to test for noise, not a sticker, opponents claimed the bill as written would not even deal with the noise violators directly.

    Opponents of the bill pointed to its lack of fairness: manufacturers are required to provide the official stamp of approval for the bike to pass inspection, but many times this stamp is not even visible. In some cases, the bike could have the legal exhaust system, but could be ticketed if it is missing the approval stamp.

    “There was an acknowledgement on all sides of the problem with the bill and it wouldn’t pass muster in court,” Comrie said. “It couldn’t be implemented as written, when you can’t determine if a pipe is legal or not.”

    Comrie said the City Council would continue to review the bill to deliver the original intention: improve the quality of life of residents whose lives are disturbed by loud motorcycle noise.

    A vote on the bill had been expected last week, but it has been delayed until the bill is finished and another public hearing - date to be determined - is held.

    Ellen Patterson, a researcher for the Concerned Citizens of Motorcycle Safety, conducted a test at several motorcycle dealerships in December to see the visibility of the EPA sticker. Of 69 bikes delivered, 24 were completely missing the sticker, and 16 of the 45 motorcycles with the sticker had it in a not-so-visible location.

    The city enacted the straight pipe ban in 1986, so bikers who ride motorcycles made before then often experience a tough time getting a pipe from the original manufacturer.

    Many bikers believe “loud pipes save lives,” since they help other motorists realize the bike is on the road. In the time of soundproof cars, iPods, and cell phones, Patterson said the 80-decibel sound limit by the city is outdated.

    “These laws were last updated in 1986, and are in need of serious review and updating to conform with modern motorcycling issues,” said Patterson, who rides a Suzuki 1000.